Years after Marcus Rutledge, 23, vanished from Nashville, secrets were unveiled about his personal life, his enrollment at Tennessee State University, and how he made money.
Earlier this year, prosecutors hoped to locate Jaynie Crosdale as a possible witness in a 2022 kidnapping case, months before kayakers found her body in a barrel.
An "evil, evil" man with a reported history of violence became the prime suspect in the double murder of Karen Barnes and Larry Ford aboard a liveaboard trawler.
Christopher LeClair claimed his wife, Karen, was terminally ill with ovarian cancer when she reportedly fell overboard a few miles from the Pennsylvania shore. But her coworkers had a different story.
Seventy-year-old sailor Fernando Silva, also known as "Captain Fredy," was rumored to have earned some Keno winnings shortly before his mysterious 2015 death.
There was more than one suspect over who purportedly dropped the body of 16-year-old Kimberly Holton out of a flying plane and into the New Jersey waters.
The Below Deck yacht captain, who now hosts Deadly Waters with Captain Lee, had some pointers for heading out to sea, including how to know when it's too dangerous to go.