Erik Hawkins

After Erin Caffey’s parents told her to break up with her boyfriend, Charlie Wilkinson, she suggested a dark plan: murdering them and her two younger brothers.

It would take years for detectives to nail Josh Gibson for shooting his ex-girlfriend Danielle Martin to death in her Powder Springs home.

Three years after the brutal shooting death of young Florida mom Heyzel Obando, Oxygen’s “Cold Justice” pitched in with the Fort Myers Police Department to help nab a suspect.

Melanie Ray and Chandler Clark lured Andre Dupuis to his death so they could flee westward in his pickup truck.

The “Cold Justice” team helped bring about arrests in the cold case murders of Cynthia Smith, Heyzel Obando, Johnnie Allbritton, and more.

Jerome Jacobson’s step-brother Marvin Braun was skeptical of the multimillion-dollar Monopoly fraud and he claimed he stopped after cashing in a $25,000 ticket.

Randy Baker didn’t appear to have an enemy in the world when someone put two bullets in him. But, his unhappy wife, Kelly, and embittered sister, Carol, may have had their eyes on a life insurance payout.

Doug Gissendaner was murdered by Greg Owen at the behest of his own wife, Kelly. 

A wild party in Mission Viejo, California ended with Steven Merritt being shot to death.

Chiquita Tate and Greg Davis were a seemingly happy Baton Rouge couple — until she was found dead in her law office in one of the most brutal murders local police could remember.