Accident, Suicide, or Murder

Bernita “Billie” Cunningham was found dead in her home in 2006 after apparently suffering a fatal fall. A closer look at the scene, however, suggested the possibility of foul play, and a years-long hunt for the truth began.

Kaylyn Whitaker was found dead from a gunshot wound in 2014, sparking a years-long pursuit for justice.

After wife and mother of two Lisa Cutler was found dead in her bathtub in the middle of the night, her husband, Chad Cutler, texted a female friend that she could move in to their house.

Tera Chavez was found fatally shot in the home she shared with her police officer husband, Levi Chavez, in 2007. What unfolded next was a battle involving numerous officers and tangled love affairs.

Vashti Seacat’s husband claimed that she killed herself and then set their house on fire. However, authorities and Vashti’s loved ones were not convinced.

When Deborah Hollermann died in a car accident in 2002, her loved ones thought it was an accident, but authorities weren’t so sure.

The media dubbed Nelson Galbraith "the Red Sash Murderer," but the couple's children never stopped trying to prove his innocence.

Although Holly Durben’s fatal shooting death was ruled undetermined, investigators believed bruising on her neck pointed toward homicide.

Tim Noble claimed his fiancée, Debbie Holden, shot herself in the head, but investigators became suspicious when he later showed up in the emergency room with the bullet in his leg.

Twins Alexandria and Anastasia Duval had a tumultuous relationship that ended in a fatal car wreck and a tense murder trial.