Kelly Siegler and the team visits Alcoa, Tennessee, to find out whether Emmaline Croft was raped and murdered at the hands of a stranger or by someone in her family.
The 11-year-old daughter of Jannette Johnson witnessed her mother park near their home after returning from a party. Johnson never made it inside, and it would take decades for authorities to identify her body.
Former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and her team are taking another look at cold cases in the Oxygen True Crime series, which returns with new episodes in 2024.
The peculiar deaths of John and Ruth High would be one of the biggest cold cases of Kelly Siegler's prolific career as a prosecutor. But not before police ruled out theories of suicide and mercy killings.