Ethan Harfenist

Nanette Johnston, Bill McLaughlin and Eric Naposki's messy love triangle ultimately led to murder and deceit.

In 1991, Robert F. Diggs, better known as RZA, was facing a felony assault charge in Ohio after he allegedly shot somebody in the leg.

Karen Ann Norton's murder in December 1985 was initially believed to have been a robbery gone wrong, but police now say her husband John Norton was responsible.

Despite several years and hundreds of miles separating the murders of Michele LaFond and Dina Kichler, a combination of thorough police work and lucky coincidences ultimately helped nab their killer.

Dina Kichler was brutally killed in December of 1990; a shockingly similar case in New Hampshire three years earlier would ultimately help bring her killer to justice.

Jacques Bloxham was caught in the act by the girl's father at an Apple store in Walnut Creek, California, according to police. 

Prisma Denisse Peralta Reyes dropped her son off with a babysitter. The Mesquite mom hasn't been heard from since.

Byron Donnell Green, 41, is charged with assault in the North Carolina attack, which both children manage to survive.

Anna Conkey was booked on charges of “making criminal threats and displaying a handgun in a threatening manner,” according to San Diego police.

NXIVM leader Keither Raniere could be the only member of the group to stand trial in the case at this point.