Two intruders stormed into the Douglass house in October 1979, robbing the family and chillingly shooting all four as they lay face down on their living room floor.
Dateline reporter Dennis Murphy described the mastermind of the gruesome plot to kill young parents Josh Niles and Amber Washburn as "perhaps the most villainous killer" he's ever come across.
Lissa Yellow Bird spent years tracking down missing Indigenous women, until one day her own niece Carla Yellow Bird disappeared, sparking a very personal mission to bring her back home.
Kathleen Peterson was found at the bottom of the staircase in her lavish North Carolina home in 2001, but the mystery around her death continues to endure.
“I don’t feel any different. And I don’t think about it,” a disappointed Liam McAtasney told a friend of how little the murder of Sarah Stern impacted him.